For this week's Critical Analysis, you will be reading 2 articles regarding a recent lawsuit regarding copyright law. You will then answer the questions below. Post your answers as a comment to this blog post—make sure to post to the correct class period's blog post.
First, read the articles below: https://www.npr.org/sections/thetwo-way/2017/09/12/550417823/-animal-rights-advocates-photographer-compromise-over-ownership-of-monkey-selfie http://time.com/5251925/peta-monkey-selfie-lawsuit-dismissed/ Next, answer these questions in complete sentences:
Larissa Esparza
4/30/2018 11:36:46 am
The articles are about a photographer, David Slater, that took a picture of a monkey, Naruto. The issue or argument that is being raised is whether or Naruto should get copyrights to the images of himself. The several organizations that were involved in the disagreement included Wikipedia, The U.S. Copyright Office, People for the Ethical Treatment of Animals, and photographer david slater.
Elizabeth Wray
4/30/2018 12:14:29 pm
These articles are about a monkey that took a selfie on a human camera. The issue is that they do not know who to give the copyright to. The photographer is David Slater, the monkey is Naruto, and other people involved are PETA and the 9th US Circuit Court of Appeals.
Lucas Prado
4/30/2018 12:12:02 pm
The lawsuit is about PETA suing a photographer, David Slater, after a macaque named Naruto took Slaters camera and took a photo of himself with it. Wikipedia and the US court were also involved, with Wikipedia refusing to take down the image due to copyright infringement.
Claire Williams
4/30/2018 12:12:08 pm
1. The first article is about the whole monkey photograph scandal and explained the lawsuit and the second article was about the trial itself and how it turned out. The issue is that a monkey took a selfie on a photographer’s camera that the he decided to publish. The PETA got involved and said that the monkey, naruto, should be the rightful owner of the work and benefit from its profits.
Payton down
4/30/2018 12:19:33 pm
1. This article is about how a monkey took a “selfie” and whether or not the monkey has the owners rights to the photo or not. People for the Ethical Treatment of Animals were involved along with David Slater, PETA.
boyd meltzer
4/30/2018 12:15:35 pm
The articles are about a lawsuit filed by the People for the Ethical Treatment of Animals against David Slater. This lawsuit was filed because Naruto, a monkey in Indonesia, pressed the shutter button on David’s smartphone and snapped a picture of himself. Thus, PETA believes that Naruto should hold the copyright for the photo and sued Slater, who owns the copyright.
Payton Down
4/30/2018 12:16:01 pm
1. This article is about how a monkey took a “selfie” and whether or not the monkey has the owners rights to the photo or not. People for the Ethical Treatment of Animals were involved along with David Slater, PETA.
Matthew Weiss
4/30/2018 12:17:45 pm
The lawsuit is over whether the monkey, Naruto, or the photographer, David Slater.
Annie Mosis
4/30/2018 12:18:00 pm
Naty Orquin
4/30/2018 12:18:21 pm
Critical Analysis #20
Jordan Bell
4/30/2018 12:22:33 pm
Both articles discuss the controversy of the monkey selfie. PETA sued David Slater for financial control of the monkey selfie. Naruto, the monkey stole Slaters camera and took a photo of himself.
Brandon Collins
4/30/2018 12:23:05 pm
1. Both articles are about a lawsuit saying , should animals have copyrights. The man being sued is David Slater. Slater is being sued by PETA. PETA is the People for the Ethical Treatment of Animals. The animal that PETA is fighting for is an ape named Naruto.
Parker Brown
4/30/2018 12:26:01 pm
1. The articles is about how what, and how PETA tries to enforce the idea that the monkey in the photo should get the rights to the photo that he took. The issue is that David Slater, the man who’s camera the monkey used, thinks he should get the rights to the photo, but PETA thinks differently.
Kylie Bruehler
4/30/2018 12:32:45 pm
What are the articles about? What is the issue, and who are the people, organizations, and animals involved?
Gilly
5/1/2018 06:03:39 pm
The articles are debating whether the monkey or the man should own the rights to a selfie the monkey took. Naruto , the monkey , found David Slater’s camera and must have been curiously looking at it and captured a photograph.There were many organizations that became involved in this situation. The U.S. Copyright Office, People of Ethical Treatment of Animals, and Wikipedia. Comments are closed.
|
AnalyzeUse this guide if you are stuck on what to write about: Archives
December 2020
Categories
All
|